A stone fireplace surround or fireplace mantel is usually the focal point of the space it occupies. Being most often the central part of the living room, getting your fireplace surround exactly right is perhaps one of the most important details of your project's many selections. Consider this: whether washing the dishes or relaxing on the sofa, you will likely see this portion of your home every single day, so why not give it a stunning look that wows every time? Having designed, crafted, and installed hundreds of fireplaces across decades of experience, working with some of the finest architects and interior designers in the industry, we consider these five factors absolutely essential when buying a stone fireplace mantel or fireplace surround. If your vendor has not mentioned or talked you through them, run.
1. Fireplace Mantel and Surround Material Selection
Choosing the right stone material is the first step toward creating an impressive fireplace surround. The options are numerous, and each type of stone lends its own character to your home.
Marble, known for its graceful veining and storied past, is a popular choice for classic environments, enhancing the elegance of any space it occupies. Frequently featuring intricate, elaborate hand carvings, marble fireplace mantels, and surrounds are a timeless yet costly option, typically ranging from $15,000 to $30,000. Marble fireplaces are also quite heavy and often necessitate strengthening the subfloor where they will be installed.
Limestone provides a gentle, rustic ambiance, ideal for those desiring a natural aesthetic. Commonly found in country-style homes or Mediterranean designs, it is adaptable enough to complement nearly any decor style. The natural color variations in limestone give it a dynamic appearance, though this can lead to some inconsistencies among the different pieces of your fireplace. Its weight is comparable to other natural stones, resulting in similar challenges with transport, scaling, and installation.
Cast Stone has long been a popular choice for stone fireplace surrounds and mantels, offering several benefits. This handcrafted stone alternative is lighter and more durable than some natural stones, providing creative flexibility by enabling the creation of large, seamless pieces. It is likely the most favored option due to its lighter weight, which makes it easier to handle and install and also allows for safer and more economical shipping. An artisan cast stone supplier can replicate natural stones with such precision that distinguishing between them is nearly impossible, though cast stone offers a slightly more consistent color and texture, lacking the natural variations found in natural stones.
Take a look at the example below, which displays a natural limestone window sill alongside a cast limestone sample that has been closely color-matched by ARCH Casting, Co. The sills are solid, heavy pieces, and a fireplace mantel or surround is significantly larger, so a full-sized natural limestone fireplace could weigh between 2000 and 3000 lbs. The Cast Limestone option below, featuring 1" thick walls, remains substantial but is much lighter, weighing approximately 600 lbs when the fireplace hearth, legs, and mantel shelf weights are combined.
2. Scale and Proportion of Your Stone Fireplace Surround
The size of your fireplace surround significantly influences the room's overall look. A large surround can attract attention to a wide area, but it might also dominate the space and seem awkward. On the other hand, a more understated design might not stand out and could seem dull, making the design feel insubstantial.
This is why it's so important to have a professional design for the fireplace to be specifically sized to your space, with the overall height of your ceilings, the width and length of the fireplace chase, and the size of the space considered. The ideal surround should not overpower the space but enhance it. For instance, a robust cast stone fireplace surround might serve as an eye-catching centerpiece in a great room measuring 20 by 30 feet. In contrast, a delicate cast limestone fireplace feature may complement a cozy den of 10 by 15 feet.
While the overall height and width of the fireplace importantly constitutes its scale, the projection is another important factor often missed. Beware, cheap fireplace manufacturers and vendors often cut down on the projection of the fireplace to reduce material, weight, and shipping costs. This ruins the fireplace feel and aesthetic like little else can, giving your fireplace surround a cheap appearance that is lacking. At ARCH Casting, Co., we recommend at least 8.5" in the project for contemporary fireplace surrounds and at least 12" or greater for fireplace mantels. This will ensure that you will have enough space for decorative pieces of all kinds to dress your mantel, and the fireplace will have an appropriate presence in the room it occupies.
3. The Symmetry & Balance of Your Stone Fireplace Surround
The symmetry and balance of a stone fireplace mantel or fireplace surround is another important factor to consider when shopping for a fireplace. It is absolutely crucial to understand design principles that should guide all the dimensional details of your stone fireplace. Make sure that your fireplace vendor does not make crucial mistakes by considering their past work
For instance, the mantel shelf should never be thinner than the width of the fireplace legs; it should instead be equal to the all-around or slightly but proportionally greater. Consider the two designs below.
The Fluted fireplace design on the left achieves balance by incorporating a flat panel above the firebox to compensate for the firebox's limited height. The slightly taller mantel, compared to the width of the legs, helps the fireplace reach a suitable height while preserving the design's symmetry and balance. In contrast, the fireplace on the right lacks height and seems awkward and bottom-heavy, with a mantel shelf that is narrower than its legs or columns.
The overall size is another crucial element influencing fireplace symmetry. When evaluating different stone fireplace designs, remember that a fireplace that is too wide but not tall will look awkward and bottom-heavy. Conversely, a fireplace that follows the dimensions of a narrow and relatively tall firebox will result in a fireplace that appears awkwardly tall and narrow.
The solution involves utilizing the inner surround paneling to create a fireplace design that is more pleasing in its shape. We can do this by modifying the panel widths of an inner surround panel to achieve an overall balanced and symmetrical height and width for the fireplace, sometimes working with and sometimes against the shape or position of the firebox. As we make the fireplace wider, we also necessarily have to make it taller, keeping even proportions throughout the elements of the stone fireplace surround. See below.
4. Fireplace Surround Seams & Joints
Dividing the stone into smaller, more manageable pieces to reduce shipping and handling expenses is a common practice among manufacturers of both cast stone and natural stone fireplace mantels and surrounds. This approach is essential due to the weight of natural marble pieces and convenient for cast stone, but it places the responsibility on your local installation vendor to ensure proper alignment and assembly of all pieces. Misalignment often occurs at the breakpoints between the stones, turning the seams into a noticeable drawback rather than a benefit. ARCH Casting, Co. is the only authentic cast stone vendor that delivers full-scale, seamless fireplace mantels and surrounds across the nation. Our distinctive method enables the creation of beautiful, seamless fireplaces, making installation straightforward since the stone fireplace surround consists of a maximum of three pieces: the fireplace surround, the hearth, and the inner surround panel. In contrast, other stone fireplace surround vendors divide each of these components into three or more pieces, resulting in a complex assembly of at least 12 pieces. Consider the two examples below.
5. Stone Fireplace Surround Texture & Color
Texture and color options are another important consideration when selecting your stone fireplace surround. It is common to rely on samples of the stone and photography of the work to gauge the beauty and quality of a stone fireplace surround finish, but in today's world, unfortunately, neither of those can be trusted 100 % of the time. Pro tip: verify the accuracy of the representation of the sample by requesting to see the stone on a larger scale or a fireplace in the showroom. Vendors often make their samples look the absolute best that they can, but unfortunately, the final result is quite lacking when the stone fireplace surround is manufactured. At ARCH Casting, Co., we proudly stand behind the color and texture consistency of our stonework. We can guarantee that the sample will look exactly like the final product or that your money back will be guaranteed.
Another important resource to consider is genuine, unedited photography of the stone fireplace surround or other cast stone products. With the advent of AI-assisted 3D modeling and ultra-realistic computer-generated photography, many companies are using computer-generated scenes to feature their stone fireplace mantels. Keeping a closer eye on the number of real-life photographs available will help you gauge the quality of a company's stonework. All of ARCH Casting, Co.'s portfolio photography are real photos taken of real projects that we have completed. Thanks to our team of production and installation experts, the work looks even better in person than on camera.
Pairing the texture, finish, and color of your stone well is another important factor to consider. Texture can play an important role in the feel of the stone almost as much as its overall shape or design. Sometimes, pairing a clean, flat finish with a more intricate fireplace profile can work to create a more transitional appeal. Applying a deeply distressed texture finish with significant depth can enhance the traditional appeal of an elaborate and grand fireplace mantel. Pairing a clean finish with a minimalist design can create a clean and calm look for your space. ARCH Casting, Co. offers unlimited color variations in three different finishes: antique french stone, honed limestone, and polished sandstone, giving you and your designer the creative latitude to develop a bespoke style that is perfect for your space.
In conclusion, selecting the appropriate stone and designing your fireplace to fit your space by taking into account scale, proportions, symmetry, and balance, and choosing a seamless stone fireplace surround in a color and texture that harmonizes with the other finishes in your home, will allow you to create the perfect stone fireplace surround for your area. This is something you will value throughout the ownership of your custom home or business space. While attending to every detail can be daunting, our team of fireplace design experts is always ready to assist in making sure your stone fireplace surround becomes a breathtaking centerpiece in your space.
Comments